News

What’s the best way to sell my jewelry?

by Andy Jones on Nov 02, 2023

What’s the best way to sell my jewelry?

Nicholas Estate Buyers specializes in buying jewelry at our physical store in Fort Lauderdale, FL. If you are unable to visit us in person, we suggest consulting your local jeweler for assistance. We prioritize providing a convenient and personalized experience for our customers.

Should I sell my jewelry?

The prices of pre-owned jewelry are considerably lower compared to new jewelry. Hence, it is advisable to consider selling your jewelry if:

You may not enjoy the style due to negative associations, but prioritize financial gains instead.

Consider resetting your diamonds and gemstones into new jewelry! Enjoy a 30% bonus on the metal value, which can be applied towards the cost of your new piece. Discover how to give your precious stones new life and create stunning jewelry. Don't miss out on this opportunity to enhance your collection!

How do I sell my jewelry?

If you're looking to sell your jewelry for cash, there are two main options available. You can either find a buyer independently, utilizing social media, word of mouth, or privately listed sales. Alternatively, you can opt for the convenience of local businesses, such as pawn shops, jewelry stores, or "We Buy Gold" establishments, which offer immediate payment. While selling independently can potentially yield higher returns, it requires more effort and time to locate a buyer. Whichever route you choose, it's important to consider the trade-offs between ease and potential profit.


If you're considering selling your jewelry, it's important to be aware that you'll likely receive a lower price compared to buying it new. Instead, think about repurposing your diamonds and gems into a new piece or saving them for future generations. If redesigning your jewelry isn't feasible right now, there are still options to explore.

Are you in Fort Lauderdale, FL? Visit our store and get a free offer on your jewelry! We only make offers in person. If you can't make it, try your local jeweler. Sell your jewelry hassle-free with us!

Will you buy my jewelry?

Looking to sell your jewelry? Visit Nicholas Estate Buyers in Fort Lauderdale, FL for a free offer! While we currently only accept in-person transactions, we understand that not everyone can make it to our location. In that case, consider checking with your local jewelry store or exploring other alternatives. We're here to help you get the best value for your precious pieces!

How much can I sell my jewelry for?

Selling jewelry becomes easier when it's in good condition and aligns with current styles or has a vintage appeal. However, most jewelry falls outside this category and is typically sold based on the value of its gold, platinum, diamonds, and gemstones. If your jewelry is in poor condition and outdated, it may only fetch its "scrap" value. In such cases, consider repurposing the gold and diamonds into a new piece. On the other hand, if your jewelry is in good condition and follows popular trends, you have the potential to earn more by selling it as a finished piece. Explore the possibilities of selling your jewelry wisely for maximum value.

If you're unsure about the right price for selling your jewelry, visit Nicholas Estate Buyers in Fort Lauderdale, FL. We provide fair offers when you bring your jewelry to our store. If you're unable to visit us, consult your local jeweler for assistance. Please note that we can only make offers on jewelry that we have physically examined.

Do I need an appraisal to sell my jewelry?

In many instances, you can sell your jewelry without requiring an appraisal. However, if your jewelry contains sizable diamonds, sapphires, emeralds, or rubies, it might be beneficial to consult a trusted jeweler for an appraisal. Discover the true worth of your precious gemstones and explore the potential value of your jewelry.

If you're selling to a private party, a written appraisal may be necessary. However, it's often not worth the expense unless you're dealing with high-value items, like pieces with larger diamonds or valuable gemstones. Save your money and consider alternatives. Find out more about selling jewelry to private parties and the importance of written appraisals.

Looking for a cost-effective option? Consider meeting your buyer at a jeweler and having a gemologist verify the piece. If you're in Fort Lauderdale, FL, check out Nicholas Estate Buyers. Our team includes accredited gemologists from both the American Gem Society (AGS) and Gemological Institute of America (GIA). If you're not local, look for an AGS or GIA gemologist. Certified Gemologist Appraiser is the highest level of certification available. Find reliable gemologist services for your needs.

Based on our experience, the value of a written appraisal for selling jewelry is often not worth the expense. The price you receive for your jewelry is primarily determined by its quality, condition, and style. Trust these factors to have a greater impact on your jewelry's worth.

Can I sell my jewelry without a receipt?

Sell your jewelry hassle-free at Nicholas Estate Buyers! No receipt required. Visit our store in Fort Lauderdale, FL for an in-person offer at no cost to you. Please note, we currently do not purchase jewelry from remote clients. If you're unable to visit our store, we recommend consulting your local jeweler for assistance.

Are you interested in selling your jewelry online or to someone you know? Determining a fair price can be a challenge, especially if you don't have a receipt. In such cases, the buyer may require an understanding of its value before making a purchase. Find out how to assess the worth of your jewelry and set a reasonable price without a receipt.

To obtain an estimate of the resale value of your jewelry, begin by visiting a nearby jeweler to receive an offer. Many jewelers, such as Nicholas Estate Buyers, provide complimentary offers with no obligation. Assessing the potential worth of your jewelry has never been easier or more accessible.

At Nicholas Estate Buyers, we provide comprehensive verbal consultations to assess, authenticate, and evaluate your precious stones. Our experts also offer valuable insights and information on your jewelry. Trust us for all your jewelry appraisal needs.

What are the top-selling types of jewelry?

When it comes to selling jewelry, many pieces often exhibit signs of wear, outdated styles, or damaged gemstones. These items are typically sold based on their intrinsic value, including the metal, diamonds, and gems, and are often disassembled. However, there are also jewelry pieces in good condition that are either current or vintage styles, especially those created prior to 1950. Selling these pieces may yield a higher return. Discover the best options for selling your jewelry and find out how vintage and current styles can impact the value of your pieces.

Factors that contribute to salability are important to consider.

When evaluating jewelry, consider its style. Is it a trendy and popular design? Or is it a vintage piece from the 1920s or earlier, which may command a higher price? On the other hand, if it's a style that was once popular but now considered dated, perhaps from the late 20th century, expect a lower price. In such cases, offers will likely be based on the intrinsic value of the individual parts.

If your jewelry has worn prongs, scratched gemstones, or chipped diamonds, don't worry! At Nicholas Estate Buyers, we offer a complimentary cleaning and inspection service. Rings and bracelets tend to experience more wear than pendants and earrings. Bring your jewelry to us for a thorough assessment and restoration. We are here to help you maintain the quality and condition of your precious pieces.

Natural round diamonds are widely sought after and highly valuable, making them the top choice for many. Ovals and cushions also hold significant value. However, marquise and princess cuts may have comparatively lower demand. Large natural round diamonds of excellent quality have better chances of being sold privately compared to most other types of jewelry. It's worth noting that lab diamonds generally have limited resale value.

Gemstones are prone to wear and tear, resulting in chips or scratches. This can significantly diminish their selling value, as the cost of recutting or resurfacing may exceed the gem's worth.

Top gemstones with high value include Sapphires, Rubies, Emeralds, and Alexandrites. Discover the allure of these precious stones and their exceptional worth.

Tanzanites, opals, aquamarine, and tourmaline are popular gemstones with medium value. Discover the allure of these stunning gemstones and add them to your collection for a touch of elegance and beauty.

Many gemstones hold little to no value compared to others in the market. Discover the true worth of precious gems and their unique characteristics.

Looking for unique and valuable jewelry pieces? Explore our collection of rare and collectible jewelry, including exquisite branded items. At Nicholas Estate Buyers, we specialize in fine jewelry and offer premium pieces that are sure to captivate. Discover the beauty and craftsmanship of these treasures today.

Looking for the best places to sell your jewelry and gold?

When it comes to selling your jewelry, you have two options to consider. The first option is to sell your jewelry to a private party. While this approach requires more effort and time, there is no guarantee of a sale. Alternatively, you can choose to sell your jewelry to a jewelry store, which offers immediate payment but at a lower price. It's important to note that Nicholas Estate Buyers only purchases jewelry in-person. If you are unable to visit us in Fort Lauderdale, FL, we recommend visiting your local jewelry store.

Your decision will depend on the amount of time and effort you are willing to invest in the selling process. Choose wisely to maximize your success in selling.

Option 1: How to Sell Your Jewelry: Find the Right Buyer for Your Precious Pieces

Maximize your earnings by focusing on popular styles of jewelry in excellent condition. However, keep in mind that selling requires considerable time and effort, and success is never guaranteed. Explore our wide selection of quality jewelry for lucrative opportunities.

Friends, loved ones, and people you know

Spread the word to your friends and family! Making connections can lead to the best offer. Need help setting a fair price? Consider a verbal consultation at Nicholas Estate Buyers in Fort Lauderdale, FL. Contact us if you're local!

Consignment Services: Convenient and Hassle-Free Solutions for Selling and Buying

The style of jewelry plays a crucial role in determining its selling price and the speed of its sale. Consignment is the ideal option when:

Our jewelry collection offers a wide range of styles, from modern pieces to exquisite antiques, with a particular focus on vintage jewelry from the 1920s and earlier. Discover our unique selection and find the perfect piece to complement your style. Browse now for timeless treasures and stunning jewelry options.


This jewelry holds significant value and is highly sought after for its quality and craftsmanship.

The jewelry is in excellent or like-new condition. There is no rush for payment at this time. Discover our stunning collection of jewelry in top condition, perfect for any occasion. No immediate payment required.

When selecting a reputable and thriving jeweler, it's crucial to avoid prolonged waiting periods or potential unsold inventory. Opt for a busy and successful jeweler to ensure a streamlined selling process for your jewelry. Don't risk losing valuable time and potential sales.

When looking for consignment policies, it's important to note that each jeweler may have their own unique set of guidelines. To gather more information, don't hesitate to reach out and inquire.

Option 2: Get an Instant Jewelry Offer and Sell Your Jewelry Fast

Selling your jewelry this way may result in a lower payout, but it offers quick and easy payment. This option is ideal for outdated or unfashionable pieces, as well as those who prefer not to sell to a third party or struggle to find buyers for their jewelry. Maximize your earnings by considering this convenient and immediate payment method.

If you're looking to sell your jewelry, you have a few options: a jewelry store, a pawn shop, or a "We Buy Gold" dealer. Typically, all three will offer you the "scrap value" of the metal, diamonds, and gems. However, in most cases, you'll get the best value for your jewelry from a reputable jeweler. It's important to note that Nicholas Estate Buyers only purchases jewelry in-person, so if you're not local to Fort Lauderdale, FL, consider visiting your local jewelry store instead.

Pawn shops are typically more suitable for pawning items rather than selling them. However, there is a slight exception: if you possess a well-worn ring in an older style, there is a chance that a pawn shop may be willing to sell it, even in its worn condition. In these specific instances, it is possible that a pawn shop might offer a higher price compared to a jeweler, although the difference is usually minimal. Discover the best options for pawning and selling at pawn shops.

If your jewelry consists mostly of metal and the diamonds and gems are small, broken, or scratched, then you are likely to receive the value of the metal only. Similar offers can be expected from various buyers. Sell your jewelry for its metal value.

If you have stylish and well-maintained jewelry with diamonds or gemstones, avoid taking it to a "We Buy Gold" establishment. These businesses often only buy the gold and remove the precious stones. It's better to visit a jewelry store that specializes in similar items for a better value and experience.

If you own jewelry with diamonds or gemstones, it's best to visit a specialized jewelry store, particularly if they are in good condition. For large diamonds or gemstones, consider consulting a custom jeweler like Nicholas Estate Buyers, known for their expertise in custom design. Custom jewelers often offer premium prices for stones, which they can incorporate into future creations. On the other hand, other jewelers may need to sell your stones on the wholesale market, resulting in a lower return for you. Choose wisely to maximize the value of your precious stones.

At Nicholas Estate Buyers, we offer a complimentary evaluation of your jewelry. Please note that we can only provide an offer after assessing the jewelry in person, and we do not purchase from remote clients. If you are unable to visit our store in Fort Lauderdale, FL, we suggest reaching out to a local jeweler for assistance. We prioritize customer satisfaction and ensuring a seamless experience for all.

Do you own jewelry in a style that doesn't suit your taste, but contains precious diamonds or gemstones you adore? Why not consider resetting them into a stunning piece that you'll cherish and wear with joy? At Nicholas Estate Buyers, we offer custom jewelry creations crafted in-house at our workshop in downtown Fort Lauderdale, FL. Our valued clients often bring us their old jewelry, selling us the metal while we repurpose their beloved diamonds and gemstones into a new masterpiece that perfectly reflects their style and personality. Discover the brilliance of sustainable jewelry reinvention at Nicholas Estate Buyers.

Our client's ring had become worn out over time. They decided to sell us the original ring as scrap, and we were able to create an identical replacement. Discover how we can help you with ring restoration and replication services.

How can I determine if my jewelry is in popular style and good condition? Find out with these simple tips and tricks!

Looking to sell your jewelry? Look no further! Our expert team can provide valuable advice on whether to sell for scrap, as a complete piece, or repurpose your diamonds and gemstones into a stunning new creation. Please note that we only accept jewelry from local clients for valuation. Visit us today for a personalized consultation!

If you have any questions or want to sell your jewelry, feel free to visit us at our Fort Lauderdale, FL store. No appointment necessary, just bring in your pieces. We buy all types of jewelry, including larger diamonds, sapphires, rubies, and emeralds. As experts in custom jewelry, we offer the best value. We look forward to assisting you and providing a seamless experience!